And justice for all: the Trail of Tears, Mexican deportation, and Japanese internment

Many textbooks mention the Trail of Tears, but fail to mention that this early displacement of an ethnic minority is only the one of many legally-sanctioned forced relocations. This lesson will address the displacement of American Indians through the Trail of Tears, the forced deportation of Mexican Americans during the Great Depression, and the internment of Japanese American citizens during WWII.

A lesson plan for grades 8 and 11–12 Social Studies

By Patricia Camp

Learn more

Related pages

• Rock art: Students will use art materials, drawings, and rock art examples to differentiate between symbol, petroglyph, pictograph, and rock art. They will also interpret rock art to illustrate its importance in the cultural heritage of a people and as a tool for learning about the past.
• North Carolina place names: This lesson contrasts and compares the names that Native Americans living in North Carolina gave to their villages and places with the names that European and other settlers gave to theirs.
• Language families: Students will identify and locate the three language families of contact period North Carolina and calculate the physical area covered by each language family.

Related topics

• Learn more about American Indians and social studies.

Legal

Learning outcomes

Students will compare and contrast different methods of racially-motivated relocations of various ethnic groups during three periods in American history.

Students will:

1. Define and discuss the difference between immigration, repatriation, deportation, resettlement, and internment.
2. Research the Trail of Tears, the deportation of Mexican Americans during the Great Depression, and the internment of Japanese Americans during WWII.
3. Compare and contrast the experiences of these three groups, the times in which they lived, and the government’s justification for their actions.
4. Present their learning to the class in the form of an oral report with visual aids, a history web, Venn diagram, or a PowerPoint (or other computer-based presentation).

Teacher planning

Time required for lesson

3 to 6 hours

Materials/resources

• grade appropriate textbooks and reference materials on Native Americans, Japanese Americans, and Mexican Americans
• paper and pencils for note-taking
• poster board for history web or Venn diagram
• dictionary or on-line dictionary

Texts:

• North Carolina: The History of an American State, third ed. John R. Bell and Jeffrey J. Crow, ISBN 1-56733-075-4.
• Created Equal: A Social and Political History of the United States, 2d ed., Jacqueline Jones, Peter H. Wood, Thomas Borstelmann, et. al, ISBN 0-321-24188-6.

Other resources:

• North American Indians (DK Eyewitness Books) by DK Publishing, ISBN 0756610818.
• Native Americans: An Inside Look at the Tribes and Traditions (DK Secret Worlds) by Laura Buller, ISBN 0-6134-5603-3.
• Decade of Betrayal: Mexican Repatriation in the 1930s by Francisco Balderrama and Raymond Rodriguez. University of New Mexico Press, 1995. ISBN 0826315755.
• I am an American: A True Story of Japanese Internment, (ALA Notable Children’s Book, Horn Book Fanfare Honor Book) (American History Classics) (Paperback) by Jerry Stanley. Crown Books for Young Readers (1996) ISBN 0517885514.

Technology resources

• computer with internet access for research
• word-processing software
• PowerPoint or other presentation software

Pre-activities

Introduce the topic by discussing with students what it feels like to move. Ask questions about moving, including:

• Have you ever moved?
• Where did you move to?
• Did you want to move?
• Did you know anyone when you got there?
• What was it like in the new place?

Students will write in their journals or on paper what the moving experience was like and how they felt about it. They should write one to two paragraphs.

Activities

1. Divide students into groups. Make sure the groups are not homogenous, as much as possible. Integrate groups by ability level, gender, ethnic background, etc. Groups should not be larger than four to six students. Four is an optimal number.
2. All students will read whatever is in their text book about the Trail of Tears. Students will go on-line and look at the interactive map of The Trail of Tears from The Museum of the Cherokee Indian. Additional websites about the Trail of Tears can be found by searching LEARN NC.
   • If this is an American history class, the introductory focus may be on the Depression and the Mexican American deportation. The Trail of Tears may have been mentioned or studied previously. In that case, examination of the bill passed in California, which became law on January 2, 2006, entitled “Apology Act for the 1930s Mexican Repatriation Program” is a good introduction. NPR radio has an oral program from the All Things Considered broadcast on 01/02/2006 which is available online. Another good resource is the Library of Congress site about Mexican immigration. This site deals with the Mexican deportation, mistakenly called repatriation.
   • If this is an American history class, an exploration of the Japanese internment may be useful. Most American history books mention the topic, and most mention that a formal apology was issued by the United States government, and reparations were paid. A good site is the “Suffering Under a Great Injustice” with photos taken by Ansel Adams at the Manazar detention camp in California.
3. Students will define the words resettlement, deportation, internment, immigration and repatriation. Discuss the difference between the meanings of each word, and the implications of each word. Students should understand the difference between the voluntary nature of immigration and the forced nature of the other terms. Terms are defined in the Critical Vocabulary section of this lesson plan.
4. Students can research first-person accounts of all three events. Good search terms are “mexican deportation” and “Trail of Tears” and “Japanese internment.”
5. Give the students the following websites or download the articles for them to read and place in a binder.
   • “Trail of Tears: Family Stories from the Trail of Tears” edited by Lorrie Montiero; Sequoyah Research Center; American Native Press Archives
   • Japanese-American Internment: Our Story in History: Life in a WWII Japanese American Internment Camp from the National Museum of American History at the Smithsonian Institution
6. Students should ask questions such as:
   • When did this event happen?
   • Why did this event occur?
   • What was going on in the United States and the world at the time the event occurred?
   • Did anyone protest the event? What was the result of their protest?
   • Were there any _________ people who were not taken away? Why weren’t they taken?
   • How did this event change American society, culture, and law?
7. Students of all age/ability groups can take the information they find and create a presentation. See the following suggestions:
   • Lower grade level students, English Language Learners, and students with reading difficulties can do history webs. History webs have an empty center with lines extending out. The center is for the title of the web, while the lines divide the surrounding space into sections. Each section should show a scene from the topic being researched. These can be done on construction paper, and the illustrations can be drawn, cut from magazines, print from the internet, etc.
   • All students can do PowerPoint presentations. The websites given, and those found through a search, will provide enough facts for a multi-slide presentation. Students can add appropriate cultural music. As an alternative, an oral report with traditional visual aids can be given.
   • Students in upper grade levels can take the information and write journal entries from the perspective of one of these displaced persons. The journals can be bound and attractively presented as books, diaries, or scrapbooks. They can be illustrated with drawings, mementoes, maps, and photos. The outside should be attractively covered. Composition books can be used for the basic book (before covered) or resources for making books are available at craft stores.
   • Gifted and motivated students may work on a number of projects. They can prepare position papers and debate their particular positions. Position papers can be written and then presented, or they can be bound together as a resource. They can also re-enact the Korematsu vs. United States or Hirabayashi vs. United States decisions. Information about the Korematsu case can be found at Landmark Supreme Court Cases. HistoryLink provides an essay about Hirabayashi. A good book useful in visualizing how to do one of these trials is Justice and Dissent: Ready-to-Use Materials for Recreating Great Trials in American History by Gary Parker Schoales 9ISBN 0-87628-752-60. Trials like this are wonderful when videotaped.

Assessment

Student projects will be evaluated on how thoroughly and accurately they compare the experiences of the three groups, accuracy of conventions (grammar, spelling, punctuation), creativity, and oral reporting skills (if used). PowerPoints can be evaluated on their thoroughness and accuracy, the number of images or slides used, and the variety of images. Journals are evaluated for the accuracy of the details expressed in the letters, creativity, attractiveness of the presentation, and other factors.

Assessment rubrics are provided for the presentation and the journal.

Supplemental information

Critical vocabulary

According to Merriam-Webster online dictionary:

• repatriate—to restore or return to the country of origin, allegiance, or citizenship
  deportation: the removal from a country of an alien whose presence is unlawful or prejudicial
• internment—to confine or impound especially during a war
• immigration—to come into a country of which one is not a native for permanent residence
• resettlement—the act of bestowing or giving possession again under legal sanction