Interdisciplinary unit, English 10 and World History 10 - Hunchback
and Reformation
This is a work in progress, created by Nancy Webber and Diane
Wildman April 2000 for LearnNC
Lesson #2
Once students have completed their list (from lesson #1), they
are ready to compare Luther's criticism with that of Victor Hugo.
Students should now create a chart in which they cite situations
which demonstrate evidence of misuse of power in The Hunchback
of Notre Dame.
|
Luther's Criticism (and brief description) |
Synopsis of scene from The Hunchback of Notre
Dame In which Luther's grievance is depicted |
Page number(s) of text evidence |
Student response and or explanation of how the
novel demonstrates Luther's complaints |
Teacher responses |
|
2= accurate criticism 1= attempted to interpret Luther's document but some aspects of the interpretation may be inaccurate or incomplete 0-no criticism described |
2 = relevant scene is identified to demonstrate Luther's grievance 1 = attempted to identify a scene but its relevance to Luther's grievance may be inaccurate or incomplete 0 = no scene was identified |
2 = page number(s) were accurate and included 1 = page numbers were inaccurate 0 = page numbers were excluded |
4 = response or explanation shows outstanding evidence that the student demonstrates a comprehensive grasp of the significant ideas Hugo is satarizing 3 = response or explanation shows strong evidence that the student demonstrates a comprehensive grasp of the significant ideas Hugo is satarizing 2 = response or explanation shows adequate
evidence that the student demonstrates a comprehensive grasp
of the significant ideas Hugo is satarizing |
Each connection is worth a maximum of 10 points.
Students are expected to gather 10 examples of
ways the novel connects. The teacher may choose to allow repetition
of grievances with the condition that the text evidence be different. 90 - 100 excellent 80 - 90 above average 70 - 80 average 60 - 70 below average below 60 - student should address the assignment again to gain a higher mastery |