LEARN NC

K–12 teaching and learning · from the UNC School of Education

Goal 4

The learner will refine critical thinking skills and create criteria to evaluate text and multimedia.

Objective 4.03

Develop the stance of a critic by:

  • considering and presenting alternative points of view or reasons.
  • remaining fair-minded and open to other interpretations.
  • creating a critical response/review of a work/topic.

Resources aligned to this objective

Interdisciplinary Integrated Unit on DNA/Genetics Part C: Language Arts
The third lesson of an interdisciplinary integrated unit on DNA and genetics, focusing on language arts. The first two lessons in the unit focus on science and math.
Format: lesson plan (grade 7 Information Skills, English Language Arts, and Computer Technology Skills)
By Jane Lentz, Jimmy White, Marlene Smith, and and Tori Goldrick.
Teaching Point of View
Students will learn point of view by comparing and contrasting the views of slaves and a doctor in The People Could Fly retold by Virginia Hamilton and The Passing Cloud -- The Southern Negro by David Morrill.

I strongly suggest the teacher previews The Passing Cloud -- The Southern Negro by David Morrill. The entire text is not needed in order for students to form an opinion or to learn point of view. Some students and parents may find the language offensive. I found the text interesting because it allows students to actually read the historical views of some people who lived in the area during the 1800's and early 1900's.
Format: lesson plan (grade 7 English Language Arts)
By Angela Strother.
TV careers: Reality vs. fantasy
In this lesson for grade seven, students discuss compare television portrayals of careers with reality.
Format: (grade 7 English Language Arts)
By Jen Presley.
What Do YOU See? (Pre-Visit)
This lesson introduces students to the importance of making accurate, detailed scientific observations, and the value of learning about others' views and perspectives regarding a specific topic or event. It also serves as an activity to prepare students for a visit to the Ackland Art Museum in Chapel Hill, NC (or any museum, real or virtual). This lesson is the first of three lessons that build upon each other, using the Ackland Art Museum as the focus.
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 Information Skills and English Language Arts)
By Reagan West.

Lesson plans on the web

Analyzing advice as an introduction to Shakespeare
Students read and analyze the advice given in Mary Schmich's 1997 Chicago Tribune column “Advice, Like Youth, Probably Just Wasted on the Young,” as an introduction to studying the advice that Polonius gives to Laertes in Shakespeare's Hamlet. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 7 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Creative communication frames: Discovering similarities between writing and art
Students will build a comparative frame to explore the creative processes of writing and art as communication. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 7 English Language Arts and Visual Arts Education)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Critical literacy: Point of view
Students learn to look at texts from different viewpoints. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–7 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Critical media literacy: Commercial advertising
Conducting an evaluation of television and magazine advertisements, students critique the effect mass media has on American culture. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 7–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Dynamic duo text talks: Examining the content of Internet sites
Students read a variety of online texts about Anne Frank and the Holocaust prior to more extensive study of these topics. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 Computer Technology Skills and English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Entering history: Nikki Giovanni and Martin Luther King, Jr.
Students read Martin Luther King Jr.’s “I Have a Dream” speech in conjunction with Nikki Giovanni’s poem “The Funeral of Martin Luther King, Jr.” in order to better understand the speech and the impact it had on observers like Giovanni during the Civil Rights movement and Americans today. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Exploring author's voice using Jane Addams Award-winning books
This lesson uses Jane Addams Award-winning books to explore author's voice and style. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Expository escapade-Detective's handbook
In this lesson, students combine reading the detective fiction genre with expository writing. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Finding the science behind science fiction through paired readings
In this lesson, students explore the genre of science fiction, while learning more about the science integrated into the plot of the story using nonfiction texts and resources. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Inventing and presenting unit 2: Effective speeches and building the invention
Students read about inventors, propose inventions to solve problems they have identified, and build and test their inventions. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–7 English Language Arts and Science)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Leading to great places in the middle school classroom
This mini-lesson examines types of leads in prominent young adult literature and challenges students to search for great leads and then write original examples. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Literature circle roles reframed: Reading as a film crew
In this alternative to traditional literature circles, students take on roles found in filmmaking, while reading and responding to a piece of literature. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Points of view in the news
Students will read articles from National Geographic News and answer questions describing each article's source, purpose, and viewpoint. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 7–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: National Geographic
Traveling the road to freedom through research and historical fiction
In this lesson, students read historical fiction and participate in a webquest to gain an understanding of an important period in American history. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Using classic poetry to challenge and enrich students' writing
In this lesson, students learn to interpret multiple perspectives while reading, analyzing, and discussing classic works of poetry. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE
Using picture books to explore identity, stereotyping and discrimination
Students are challenged to analyze the concepts of identity, stereotyping and discrimination by reading picture books that depict characters who are different from others in their communities. (Learn more)
Format: lesson plan (grade 6–8 English Language Arts)
Provider: IRA/NCTE